EN
AR
CS
FR
DE
EL
HI
IT
JA
KO
PL
PT
RU
ES
TL
ID
SR
SK
VI
HU
TH
TR
FA
UR
LA
PA
Choosing the wrong shade of "red" could result in your product being banned worldwide
Carmine vs. Cochineal Red — The "Hundred-Million-Dollar" Trap Hiding in a Single Character Difference
In the context of Chinese procurement, "Carmine" and "Cochineal Red " differ by only one character. However, in international trade, they represent two completely different substances, two sets of completely different regulations, and two completely different market fates.
l Carmine (Ponceau 4R / E124): Chemical synthetic azo dyes are explicitly prohibited in the United States, Canada, and Norway. The European Union requires labeling that "may have adverse effects on children's attention and activity".
l Cochineal Red(Carmine / E120): Extracted from natural cochineal insects, it complies with global standards in all major markets and perfectly aligns with the Clean Label trend.
Warning: If your target market is in Europe or America, using this one wrong word will result in the entire shipment being seized, the supplier's qualifications being blocked, and irreversible damage to the brand reputation!
A table makes it clear: E124 vs E120
| Dimension | Carmine (E124) | Cochineal Red (E120) |
| Source | Petroleum-derived synthetic (Azo dye) | Naturally extracted from cochineal insects |
| US FDA | ❌ Not permitted for food use | ✅ Approved for use |
| Canada | ❌ Prohibited | ✅ Approved for use |
| Norway | ❌ Prohibited | ✅ Approved for use |
| EU Labeling | ⚠️ Mandatory warning statement for children's health | ✅ No special warning requirement |
| Clean Label | ❌ Does not meet Clean Label requirements | ✅ Clean Label compliant |
| ADI (Acceptable Daily Intake) | 0.7 mg/kg body weight (EFSA 2009, reduced level) | 5 mg/kg body weight |
| Price Positioning | Low-cost option | Premium ingredient (approximately 20–50× higher value) |
Make your "red" red in a proper way and red with peace of mind
Kennture Bio offers a full range of natural colorants that are globally compliant, including natural Carmine (E120), Beet Red (E162), and β-Carotene (E160a). Each batch comes with complete regulatory compliance documents, ensuring that your products can smoothly enter the markets in Europe and the United States.